Report: Despite UNRWA Promises, Teachers Again Inciting to Violence Against "Jewish Apes and Pigs"

ethics certificate for suad

Above: UNRWA’s “Certificate of Ethics” for teacher who posts on Facebook
that “Zionists and Jews” are “sons of apes and pigs.” 

GENEVA, November 30, 2015 – Despite prior promises by UNRWA, the Palestinian relief agency, to put an end to online incitement by its teachers, numerous UNRWA teachers are still inciting to Palestinian knife attacks against what they describe as “Jewish apes and pigs,” and should be fired, according to a new report issued today by UN Watch, the Geneva-based watchdog group. See full report below.
“UNRWA’s reported temporary suspensions of offenders are clearly not working. Giving a slap on the wrist sends the message that it’s business as usual. Instead, those who incite to racism or murder should be fired, under a zero tolerance policy, just as the UK government recently banned a teacher from the classroom for life over an anti-Semitic Facebook post,” said Hillel Neuer, executive director of UN Watch.
UN Watch submitted the report today to UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, UNRWA chief Pierre Krähenbühl — as well as to EU foreign affairs commissioner Federica Mogherini, and U.S. Ambassador Samantha Power, whose governments are the top funders of UNRWA, for a combined total of almost $1 billion U.S. last year.
Today’s report, coming after previous UN Watch reports this year on 22 other individuals, documents yet another 10 UN teachers, principals and other staffers who use the imprimatur of their official positions to incite Palestinian stabbing and shooting attacks against Israeli Jews.
“The UN and top funders of UNRWA such as the United States government must act immediately to terminate employees who are inciting murderous anti-Semitism and fueling the deadly pandemic of Palestinian attacks against Israeli Jews that have claimed the lives of innocent men, women and children,” said Neuer.
“We urge Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon to personally intervene because UNRWA has abjectly failed to uphold its promises to stop the poison,” said Neuer. “We urge Mr. Ban to take immediate action to terminate any UN employees who incite to murder.”
“Moreover, we call for the establishment of an independent commission of inquiry, to include representatives of the U.S., the EU (which gave UNRWA $139 million last year), the UK ($95 million), and other top UNRWA funders, to investigate the culture of impunity for perpetrators of racism and incitement that pervades UNRWA.”
“UNRWA’s strategy of impunity, denial and deflection only enables more incitement and violence. It’s time to put an end to the pattern and practice of UNRWA school principals, teachers and staff members posting antisemitic and terror-inciting images, a recurring theme that suggests a pathology of racism and violence within UNRWA, one that must be rooted out — and not buried, as UNRWA spokesman Chris Gunness has attempted to do by calling for boycotts of newspapers or of NGOs that dare to report these incidents of hate,” said Neuer.
“We’re urging the UN to declare unequivocally that these despicable posts, published on Facebook accounts run by people who openly identify themselves as UNRWA officials, constitute a gross violation of UNRWA Staff Regulations, and of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which prohibits incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence,” said Neuer.
Neuer said the teachers’ incitement to racism and violence constitues a “gross violation” of UNRWA Regulation 1.4 which requires staff members to conduct themselves “at all times in a manner befitting their status as international civil servants,” and not to engage “in any activity that is incompatible with the proper discharge of their duties with the Agency.” Specifically, they “shall avoid any action and in particular any kind of public pronouncement which may adversely reflect on their status or integrity, independence or impartiality which are required by that status,” and “shall at all times bear in mind the reserve and tact incumbent upon them by reason of their international status.”
In light of the report’s damning findings, UN Watch is again demanding a full apology from UNRWA spokseman Chris Gunness for a series of unprofessional tweets against what he called UN Watch’s “baseless allegations about antisemitism.”

Gunness sought to discredit UN Watch, issuing an “appeal to journalists” to ignore what he insisted was a “non-story”:

  • “Appeal to journalists: please don’t turn UN Watch baseless allegations about anti-semitism into a ‘he said she said’ story. It is a non-story.”
  • “UN Watch makes a fool of itself … Credibility dead in water. Will anyone believe them again”?
  • “Interested to find out more about UN Watch’s political and financial affiliations since it establishment. Can anyone advise?”


Climate Change for UNRWA

A Report on Ongoing Incitement Despite
UNRWA’s Promises of Accountability


UN Watch Report
November 30, 2015



Mohammed Al Jowhary - FB profile UNRWA link

Mohammed Al Jowhary of Jordan (aka Mohammad Jumah Al Jawhary), who identifies himself on his Facebook Profile as an UNRWA teacher, posted the photo below on October 27, 2015, the same day on which two Israeli soldiers were stabbed and wounded by Palestinians. Knives are portrayed as women’s earrings, with the caption “New accessories for Palestinians.” 

Mohammed Al Jowhary - Offending image

This is one of numerous examples of violent incitement on Mr. Jowhary’s Facebook timeline, as well as posts that use Jihadist language to describe those attacking Israelis as victims and sacred martyrs.
Yet despite hiRight to play with colleagues long record of inciting to violence, UNRWA school principal Abo Allaith Seafan (seen in photo, right) — whose own Facebook timeline includes graphic scenes of blood-splattered bodies, violence, and incitement — recently presented Mr. Jowhary with a special coaching certificate from the Toronto-based organization Right to Play, which is supposed to use sports to teach peace.
UNright to play Watch calls on Johann Koss, CEO and President of Right to Play — which is partially funded by the Canadian government — to immediately revoke this certificate of a teacher inciting to racism and murder as someone who shows “leadership and commitment” as a “coach for Right to Play’s programme in Jordan.”
Likewise, UN Watch calls on the British Council, sponsor in Jordan of the World Voice Programme, and Artistic Director Richard Frostick (seen below with Mr. Jowhary on November 12, 2015, in a seminar at the Millenium Hotel in Amman) to revoke his certificate as an “Ambassador for the World Voice Programme,” due to the UNRWA teacher’s engagement in incitement to murder. 

Recommendation: UNRWA should fire Mohammed Al Jowhary for using the name of UNRWA on an account which incites acts of terrorism, in gross violation of UNRWA Staff Rule 1.4. Right to Play, and the British Council’s World Voice Programme, should both revoke their certificates to Mr. Jowhary.



Mazen Abo Hady - FB profile UNRWA linkMazen Abo Hady, identifying himself on his Facebook profile as an UNRWA teacher in Gaza, engages in virulent incitement to murder Jews.
On October 10th, Abo Hady posted the image below — also posted by fellow UNRWA employee Hiba Maria, as detailed in a previous report by UN Watch — which shows a keffiyeh-clad Palestinian playing a knife like a violin, using a Palestinian ‘key of return’ as a bow.
Mazen Abo Hady - Offending image 2 - knife violin
Screen Shot 2015-11-30 at 1.52.35 AMIt gets worse. On October 13th, the day when Palestinians carried out four separate terrorist attacks against Israelis — including an attack on a Jerusalem bus, and a car-ramming followed by murder with a meat cleaver, attacks which killed Haviv Haim, 78, and Rabbi Yeshayahu Krishevski, 60 — UNRWA teacher Abo Hady rushed to celebrate their deaths.
First, by exclaiming “God is great.”

Second, by celebrating the attackers as “martyrs,” in multiple posts, and uploading their photos to his Timeline:
Screen Shot 2015-11-30 at 1.51.38 AM
Third, by celebrating the murder of Rabbi Krishevski and posting his photo, together with a keffiyeh-wearing man tearing through an Israeli flag with a bloodied knife, to reveal a scene in which the Palestinian flag flies atop the Al-Aqsa Mosque. Click here and here to see the original posts.
Screen Shot 2015-11-30 at 1.51.46 AM

Mazen Abo Hady - Offending image I - flag
Recommendation: UNRWA should fire teacher Mazen Abo Hady for using the name of UNRWA on an account that glorifies violent acts of terrorism, celebrates the murderers, and mocks the murder of innocents, all in gross violation of UNRWA Staff Rule 1.4.



Suad Assi - FB profile UNRWA link
Suad Assi of Ramallah (aka Suad Khalil Remawi), identifying himself as an UNRWA English teacher on his Facebook profile, shared the post below about “enemies”, saying that it is important to know that “the Zionists and the Jews are sons of monkeys and pigs”:
Suad Assi - Offending image with text
Other virulent incitement on his Facebook page includes his posting of this video which portrays Palestinian knife attackers as innocent victims:
Screen Shot 2015-11-30 at 2.28.52 AM
Ironically, this UNRWA teacher proudly displays his UNRWA certificate of ethics:
ethics certificate for suad
Recommendation: UNRWA should fire Suad Assi for inciting to anti-Semitism and terrorism, in gross violation of UNRWA Staff Rule 1.4.



Fedaa Elnadi Jad Elhaq - FB profile UNRWA linkDr. Fedaa Elnadi Jad Elhaq  (aka Dr. Fedaa Masoud Ibrahim Elnadi), who identifies herself as an UNRWA medical officer on her Facebook page, shared the post below on July 13, 2014, in which she exalts Islamic martyrdom, saying “Palestinians grew up wanting nothing but dying as Martyrs. So whether Palestinians win this worldly war or not; they’re the winners.”
Screen Shot 2015-11-30 at 2.48.33 AM
On the same day, she also published the post below exalting armed struggle, saying “Existence is Resistance.” A keffiyeh in the shape of the entirety of Israel and the Palestinian Territories accompanies text in which Palestinian fighters are lauded as paradigms of heroism. 
Amir Orabi - Offending image
“Oh God, you Jews,” wrote the UNRWA doctor on July 18, 2014, in one of many references to Jews:
Screen Shot 2015-11-30 at 2.54.33 AM

Recommendation: UNRWA should fire Dr. Fedaa Elhaq for using the name of UNRWA on an account that promotes violence, in gross violation of UNRWA Staff Rule 1.4.



Bahaa Abed El Jawwad - FB profile UNRWA link
Bahaa Abed El Jawwad, who identifies himself on his Facebook page as an UNRWA teacher, posted the images below in July 2014 (view original here) and November 2012 (view original here). The first shows a young man, masked and crouching, preparing to hurl rocks. The second depicts two young men, again masked, this time wielding machine guns. The caption reads ‘Gaza resists.’ 
Bahaa Abed El Jawwad - offending image Bahaa Abed El Jawwad - offending image 2
Recommendation: UNRWA should fire Bahaa Abel El Jawwad for using the name of UNRWA on an account that promotes violence and contravenes his obligation to be neutral, in gross violation of UNRWA Staff Rule 1.4.



Afnan Badawi (f) - FB profile UNRWA link
Afnan Badawi, who identifies herself on her Facebook page as a teacher at UNRWA, has since August 2014 had as her cover photo an image of masked Palestinians rocking a burning skip in 2014’s ‘Day of Anger.’ Below is a photo that she published to her account in August 2014, in which members of Hamas’s military wing, the Al-Qassam Brigades, pray next to their guns.
Afnan Badawi (f) - Offending image
Recommendation: UNRWA should fire Afnan Badawi for using the name of UNRWA on an account which condones violence and contravenes her obligation to be neutral, in gross violation of UNRWA Staff Rule 1.4.



Obeida or Palestine - FB profile UNRWA link

An unnamed UNRWA employee, whose Facebook account is under the name ‘Mother Palestine’ (see above), responded to the explosion in terrorism that has rocked Israel over the past month by posting inflammatory content condoning the violence. Below is a photo, taken on and uploaded from the individual’s mobile phone, of two masked individuals armed with a large knife (held as if in preparation to stab) and a gun, respectively.

Obeida or Palestine - Offending image 1 - knife

‘Mother Palestine’ also posted a propaganda video on Facebook in which an array of belligerent acts are set to music. Below are two still images from the video.

Obeida or Palestine - Offending image 3 - video still 2Obeida or Palestine - Offending image 2 - video still 1
Recommendation: UNRWA should fire this employee for using the name of UNRWA on an account that promotes violence and celebrates violence and terrorism, in gross violation of UNRWA Staff Rule 1.4.



Muhannad Nabulsih - FB profile UNRWA link
Muhammad Nabulsih, identifying himself as an UNRWA employee on his Facebook page (directly above), updated his profile picture on October 10, 2015 to his current one, an image of a man hurling stones alongside the caption “The Uprising Begins.”
In March, he made his profile photo that of Sheikh Ahmed Yassin, founder of the Hamas terrorist group:
Screen Shot 2015-11-30 at 3.00.38 AM
This time last year, Nabulsih posted the photograph below of Muataz Hijazi, the Islamic Jihad terrorist who shot Rabbi Yehuda Glick, the well-known Israeli activist for Jewish prayer rights on Temple Mount, on October 29, 2014, and who was himself shot dead in the aftermath.
Muhannad Nabulsih - Offending image 2 mugshot
Recommendation: UNRWA should fire Muhammad Nabulsih for using the name of UNRWA on an account which celebrates violence and terrorism, in gross violation of UNRWA Staff Rule 1.4.



Ruad Hussein - FB profile UNRWA linkRuad Hussein, who identifies himself on his Facebook profile (above) as an UNRWA employee, shared two inflammatory posts below on his Facebook Timeline on October 10th, in the midst of the current Palestinian attacks on Jews. The original posts can be seen here and here.

Ruad Hussein - Proof of post of offensive imagesRuad Hussein - Proof of post of offensive images 2

Recommendation: UNRWA should fire Ruad Hussein for using the name of UNRWA on an account that promotes violence and contravenes his obligation to be neutral, in gross violation of UNRWA Staff Rule 1.4.



Mohammad Abu Musa - FB profile UNRWA link
Mohammad Abu Musa, who identifies himself as an UNRWA employee on his Facebook page, posted the image below in July 2014, in which he calls for armed resistance. The picture shows a gun overlaid with the text: “We are with the resistance.”
Mohammad Abu Musa - Offending picture
Recommendation: UNRWA should fire Mohammad Abu Musa for using the name of UNRWA on an account which promotes violence and contravenes his obligation of neutrality, in gross violation of UNRWA Staff Rule 1.4.

UN Watch