Hillel Neuer: “The decision of the National Council of Switzerland to cut the aid is very significant. The Member of Parliament who brought the motion, whose name is David Zuberbühler, said: “It’s an open secret that UNRWA schools continue to glorify terrorism, incite violence, and promote antisemitism.” These are the words of the Swiss MP. He said a majority of the National Council has finally recognized this.
So certainly our organization, UN Watch, which is based in Switzerland, has published numerous times in Swiss media the fact that UNRWA teachers systematically incite to antisemitism, the fact that UNRWA schools have been used by Hamas to hide rockets and to hide weapons. So all of this is known in Switzerland. And I think it’s quite significant that the lower house has taken this step at this time, even if so far the Senate has not approved it.”
i24 News: “UNRWA is unique anyway, isn’t it? It’s the only refugee agency that looks after the descendants of refugees. As I mentioned in the introduction, its budget is about $1 billion a year, largely coming from American and European taxpayers. What does it actually do for the Palestinian people?”
Hillel Neuer: “Actually, it’s the Swiss Foreign Minister five years ago, Ignazio Cassis, after visiting UNRWA facilities in the region, he said UNRWA is part of the problem, not part of the solution. As you said, Laura, he said, they’re perpetuating the refugee problem. They’re not solving it. And he said, the fact that we’re paying for it is perverse.
So unlike the UN Refugee Agency, which was also in Geneva, the UNHCR, their job is to resettle refugees, to make them no longer refugees, UNRWA does the opposite. They’ve taken what were a few 100,000 refugees back in 1948, 1949 and made them into 6 or 7 million. And they’re doing everything not to resettle them. So if someone from Gaza wants to flee and go to America or to the West, UNRWA will say no, you are always a refugee and you always need to go back to pre-1967 Israel. So they speak of a two-state solution, but the narrative is basically to dismantle Israel itself.”
i24 News: “Now, you’ve been talking about this for many years, Hillel. But do you think this war has opened a lot of people’s eyes as to what exactly UNRWA is?”
Hillel Neuer: “The fact that the majority, a large majority in the lower house of the Swiss parliament voted to defund UNRWA shows that we’ve reached a certain point. By the way, this happened on the same day that Switzerland voted to ban Hamas, unanimously. So those happened together, at the same time, it’s not accidental. The same Swiss parliament that banned Hamas voted to defund UNRWA.
As I said, the Senate did not approve it. But that indicates that even Switzerland, neutral Switzerland, has enough people that have begun to wake up. That an agency that claims to be solving the problem is actually perpetuating it. We need to do something, we can’t let things remain business as usual. And we should help Palestinians, they need help. But the fact that there’s a political agenda-driven agency that is managing all of this, we’ve seen that they haven’t solved anything. And in fact, they’re the ones who educated the terrorists of October 7, many of them are graduates of UNRWA schools.”
For the latest UN Watch posts on the Hamas-Israel war, click here