Dramatic U.N. Clash; Israeli Rocket Victim Asks Goldstone: “Why Were You Silent?”

Agenda Item 7, UNHRC, 12th Session
Interactive Dialogue with Fact-Finding Mission on Gaza
UN Watch Statement, delivered by Dr. Mirela Siderer

Click for video

Thank you, Mr. President.

My name is Dr. Mirela Siderer.  I am a gynecologist living in Ashkelon, Israel.

Judge Goldstone, in July you invited me to testify. I told you my story.

I am known by my patients-including many women from Gaza.  For me, every human being is equal.

On May 14, 2008, my life was changed forever.  I was working in my clinic. Suddenly, the building was hit by a missile, fired from Gaza.

I was terribly wounded.  Blood was everywhere.  My patient was also wounded, and more than one hundred others.  Next month will be my eighth operation.

Judge Goldstone, I told you all of this, in detail.  I testified in good faith. You sent me this letter, saying, “Your testimony is an essential part of the Mission’s fact-finding activities.”

But now I see your report.  I have to tell you: I am shocked.

Judge Goldstone, in a five-hundred page report, why did you completely ignore my story?  My name appears only in passing, in brackets, in a technical context.

I feel humiliated.

Why are there only two pages about Israeli victims like me, who suffered thousands of rockets over eight years?

Why did you choose to focus on the period of my country’s response, but not on that of the attacks that caused it?

Why did you not tell me that this Council judged Israel guilty in advance, in its meeting of last January?

Why did you not tell me that members of your panel signed public letters judging Israel guilty in advance?

Judge Goldstone, you, too, signed such a letter, saying you were “shocked” about Gaza.

But where were you when Gaza attacked my medical clinic, in violation of international human rights and humanitarian law?

Where was this Council?

Why were you all silent?

Thank you, Mr. President.


Goldstone’s Response:

With regard to the statement made by Dr. Siderer, I’m clearly upset that she feels humiliated by the report. She was treated in the report in no way different to that of other victims who spoke to us. She was referred to in the report as one of the people who was injured as a result of a rocket attack on a shopping center in Southern Israel.  The report also refers to the fact that the evidence of the people who gave evidence to us are available on the website of the OHCHR. It is there for anybody to see.


UN Watch Note: Dr. Siderer posed 8 simple questions. Goldstone avoided all except one, and on this was non-responsive and misleading. Dr. Siderer never said that she wasn’t “referred to,” but rather complained that her story was ignored, and her name mentioned only “in passing, in brackets, in a technical context;” and that this only underscored how Goldstone downplayed 8 years of suffering of rocket victims like her.


Share on facebook
Share on twitter


In the News

UN Watch in the News — August 2021

UN Watch was quoted in multiple media outlets during August 2021 on topics including: UNRWA responds to UN Watch report; Afghanistan falls to the Taliban;

Top Tweets Afghanistan

Telling The Truth About The Taliban

As the Taliban took control of Afghanistan, many worldwide turned to UN Watch for the truth about the misogynistic terrorist group. Below are some our

In the News

UN Watch in the News — July 2021

UN Watch was quoted in multiple media outlets during July 2021 on topics including: International Criminal Court opens war crimes investigation into Israel; Human Rights

UN Watch’s Top Tweets in July 2021

Trending UN Watch tweets from July: Iranian plot to kidnap dissident Masih Alinejad in New York foiled by FBI; Israeli and Saudi judokas embrace after